Married at First Sight’ stars David and Madison had some big updates regarding their relationship to share with the cast during the reunion show

"I think all of us knew that Michelle and David were not going to be together at the end of this," Madison claims in PEOPLE’s exclusive first look at Feb. 25 episode of 'Married at First Sight'

More than a year after David and Madison’s “grimy” affair was exposed, the two joined the rest of the Married at First Sight Chicago cast for the season’s reunion special. While their relationship began in dubious circumstances, it proved to be surprisingly enduring. One year after filming ended, they were still together.